| School Name | API (2009) | API (2008) |
| James L. Bunker Elementary | 843 | 844 |
| Lincoln Elementary | 798 | 792 |
| John F. Kennedy Elementary | 794 | 798 |
| H. A. Snow Elementary | 792 | 783 |
| Louis Milani Elementary | 771 | 743 |
| E. L. Musick Elementary | 756 | 742 |
| Newark Junior High | 756 | 774 |
| James A. Graham Elementary | 746 | 748 |
| Newark Memorial High | 723 | 734 |
| August Schilling Elementary | 717 | 715 |
| Crossroads High (Alternative) | 579 | 604 |
| Bridgepoint High (Continuation) | 559 | 605 |
| Progressive Academy | | |
| Newark Adult High | | |
| New Beginnings Academy | | |